A $45 Million Post-It Note Gift
A $45 million transfer on two Post-it notes sounds like a punchline, but it lands in the BC Court of Appeal with real consequences. We break down a British Columbia family law dispute where a preservation order under section 91 of the Family Law Act is meant to stop assets from being moved while spousal support and property-division claims are still alive. The twist is the defence: the money “wasn’t really mine” because it was held for someone else as the beneficial owner.
We also get into why civil contempt is its own demanding corner of the law. The courts expect precision, clear allegations, and clear orders, yet the Court of Appeal still finds the breach and sends the case back for a penalty decision. That raises an uncomfortable practical question: what does punishment even look like when a person can part with $45 million as casually as signing a note?
Then the focus shifts to negligence law in Canada after a stabbing at Matsqui Institution, a federal penitentiary in BC. Even with a conceded duty of care to protect inmates, the claim against the Attorney General of Canada fails on the hardest parts of negligence: whether the harm was reasonably foreseeable and whether the outcome is too remote to pin on the government, even when an officer doesn’t follow a verification rule.
If you care about Canadian law, court orders, and how judges draw lines in messy real life, you’ll find a lot to debate here. Subscribe, share the episode with a friend, and leave a review, then tell us which decision you think the courts got right?
Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan is live on CFAX 1070 every Thursday at 12:30 p.m. It’s also available on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.