Flight Compensation and Your Car Knows Too Much

Frustrated by an airline refusing compensation for your delayed flight? You might have more power than you think. Legal expert Michael Mulligan walks us through a fascinating Civil Resolution Tribunal case where passengers successfully challenged WestJet’s weather-related excuses and secured $1,000 each in compensation. By gathering evidence showing other airlines operating during the supposedly problematic conditions, these passengers demonstrated how everyday Canadians can effectively navigate the Air Passenger Protection Regulations through BC’s accessible online tribunal system.

The conversation shifts to judicial impartiality with a cautionary West Vancouver demolition dispute. When a judge ordered a fire-damaged house demolished, no one realized she had previously advised the municipality on that very case before her appointment to the bench. This oversight led the Court of Appeal to cancel the injunction, highlighting the critical importance of judicial independence and the challenges judges face in identifying conflicts without the robust database systems used by law firms.

Perhaps most eye-opening is the revelation about what your modern vehicle knows and remembers about your driving. Event data recorders in today’s cars capture crucial information during accidents – your speed, whether you were wearing a seatbelt, and if you applied the brakes before impact. In a groundbreaking decision, a court determined that this extracted data constitutes a “thing” rather than a “document” under criminal code provisions, requiring police to obtain judicial permission to retain it when no charges have been filed. This legal distinction reinforces important protections against indefinite police retention of digital evidence.

Whether you’re planning air travel, wondering about judicial ethics, or simply curious about what your car might reveal after an accident, this discussion offers valuable insights into how our legal system addresses everyday challenges in an increasingly technological world.

 

Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan is live on CFAX 1070 every Thursday at 12:30 p.m. It’s also available on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.